Coaches Pizza

Coaches Pizza in Waverly, NY, is a standout destination for pizza lovers seeking a delightful, satisfying meal with the convenience of meal delivery. Specializing in classic and inventive pizza creations, this cozy local gem offers a menu that truly caters to both traditional tastes and adventurous appetites.

Step into Coaches Pizza and you'll immediately sense the inviting, clean atmosphere—perfect for a casual meal or a quick bite on the go. The aroma of freshly baked dough and bubbling cheese fills the air, setting the stage for a comforting and indulgent experience. Among their crowd-pleasers, the Sheet Pizza stands out as a hearty, flavorful option that’s great for sharing or freezing for later. For those who crave a little extra zest, the Honey BBQ Chicken Pizza brings a sweet and smoky twist that harmonizes beautifully with tender chicken pieces and tangy BBQ sauce.

Beyond pizza, Coaches Pizza showcases an impressive variety of salads and sandwiches that complement their pies perfectly. The Spring Training salad selection—from the crisp, refreshing Garden Salad to the protein-packed Steak Salad—offers a great balance for a lighter meal or an appetizing start. Their subs are equally tempting, with options like the savory Chicken Cheesteak and the spicy Buffalo Chicken delivering bold flavors packed between fresh, soft bread. The Wolverine Wraps bring portability and flavor together, with fillings like Chicken Spiedie and Turkey that make every bite satisfying.

Customer feedback echoes the quality and warmth Coaches Pizza delivers. Amy Dixon describes it as “a great little place” and even calls their pizza “the best we ever had,” showing the genuine delight that comes from an honest, great-tasting meal. Randy Schurter praises their “quick and friendly service,” making every order feel like a personal experience, while Danielle Cash’s enthusiasm for “the absolute best pizza ever” from out of state speaks volumes about Coaches’ wide-reaching appeal. Local regular Jackie Vajda shares how Coaches Pizza has won over her kids and family, highlighting how their sheet pizza is a household staple and the Honey BBQ wings a family favorite.

Whether you’re a local or visiting Waverly, Coaches Pizza offers a comforting taste of home with a menu that delivers on flavor, freshness, and friendly service. It’s the kind of place you want to return to before you even leave town.